Author transcript
Sean Nolan: Hello and welcome to CX Today. My name is Sean Nolan. Brand loyalty is inherently based on the emotional connection between a consumer and a retailer. But how will that work in a world where AI agents are doing the shopping? Here to discuss what brands need to keep in mind in the era of agentic commerce is Jason Gregory, VP of Product at VoucherCodes. Hi Jason, thank you so much for your time today and for joining me on CX Today. To start things off, can you introduce yourself and tell us about VoucherCodes.co.uk?
Jason Gregory: So I'm Jason Gregory, VP of Product at VoucherCodes. We're the UK's leading savings site, and our mission since 2008 has been to make the lives of people in the UK more affordable. We work with thousands of brands across the UK in the food, fashion, travel, and homeware categories to offer discounts, advertising, and valuable insights that help businesses grow, but also help consumers find the best offers and deals when they're shopping online. My team of product managers and designers are really focused on how we help customers save and earn every time they shop with us.
Sean Nolan: Perfect, thank you so much. Today we're going to be talking a little bit about agentic commerce. There's this really big change and shift that's coming in retail. As personal AI agents become increasingly popular amongst the general public and are relied upon for shopping, how do you see that affecting customer loyalty moving forward?
Jason Gregory: I think this is almost the billion dollar question that the retail industry is grappling with at the moment. I've been at businesses in the past where conversational commerce has had its moment, and there are plenty of examples now where businesses have effectively introduced AI-level chatbots into their customer service teams, and they're on the whole really good these days. But now it feels like we're at the inflection point where the technology and the capabilities of large language models have enabled this human-like shopping experience to happen at scale, and to happen on the discovery side of shopping, as opposed to the functional customer experience side of things. There's no doubt that the likes of the Universal Commerce Protocol from Google and Shopify is going to help unlock that and accelerate that further.
In terms of what it means for customer loyalty, if we take a step back and think about what that actually is, I would define it as the trust, the quality, and the positive emotional connection that a brand creates with customers. Generally that's sustained over a long period of time. It's not something that you earn the first time a customer uses your product or your business. So in terms of the impact, if your customer loyalty is surface level, if it's built solely around something like convenience, then I'd be more concerned about what the future might have in store, versus if your loyalty and your affinity with the customer is much more deeply interconnected with your whole proposition.
There are plenty of great examples of retailers out there who have fantastic membership programs alongside really great delivery propositions, great customer service, great personalization as well. But I would always come back to really understanding, as a brand, what loyalty means to them. It is a very real, felt value, and it's quite difficult to replace. So in this new era, the way we're thinking about it a bit is: would the customer tell their agent about us or about our loyalty program? I think that's an interesting way to look at it, because you want to be building a proposition and a service that the customer is willing to name and willing to advocate for within these new agentic experiences that are becoming more prevalent.
Sean Nolan: Yeah, absolutely. It's a really good point. For example, if you're shopping at Sainsbury's and you want to stack up your Nectar points, if you feel really strongly about that, you might say to your agent, "I have a preference for this particular shop because I have this membership program and these points that I want to collect." But it's about whether humans are actually going to prompt their AI to search along that path, or are they simply going to go along with things like affordability and delivery prices and other factors that might swing their preference, as opposed to that customer loyalty that keeps bringing them back. It's a really important question that needs to be asked.
Next, I want to ask: are you concerned that businesses may start to pivot to winning that initial sale and that initial purchase from the customer, but then fail to invest in that loyalty strategy when agents do the shopping? There might be that temptation for brands to focus on, okay, we just need to get that initial sale and then we're happy. Whereas without that human touch now, they may fail to see the value of that brand loyalty.
Jason Gregory: I think that's a really interesting question for businesses at the moment. I think when any new channel emerges, the instinct to capitalize on it is very understandable. We've always seen that, from the early days of search on the internet through to social and now obviously with AI. Fundamentally, getting discoverable through agents is going to be really important, but I don't think discoverability alone is going to be enough for retailers and for brands. Regardless of the technology shifts we've seen and the consumer behavior shifts we've seen over time, that's never really been just enough. Even if you've been at the top of Google search results or you're recommended through Instagram, there's still a connection that you need to build and win with the customer from that moment onwards.
So I think the winners are ultimately going to be the businesses that are investing in both that discoverability and also how their experience and their products interplay with agents, and their customer loyalty propositions or products. I think those simple journeys are going to be quite disrupted. So just basic purchases where the consumer is looking for a specific thing, you can totally see how an agent could take care of that on behalf of the consumer. But a lot of what people are doing is a little bit more complex than that.
A big investment for us at VoucherCodes has been our VIP proposition. That's a loyalty program designed around rewarding customers with every qualifying purchase. So the more they shop through VoucherCodes, the more chances they have to save and earn. When I think about loyalty for other brands, that post-purchase experience feels like a really good opportunity. Brands who can demonstrate that they really understand the needs of the customer, that they can provide personalized recommendations and experiences, and win that post-purchase part of the funnel, will do really well.
I don't think the likes of Gemini or Claude will really want to own that part of the customer journey when shopping. It's always been one of the most difficult things to get right for businesses. It's the bit where you genuinely own the relationship with the customer. They're invested because they bought a product they really want. They want to make sure it arrives on time, and you want to make sure everything else that happens beyond that point weaves into your proposition. So I think it is still important for brands to make sure, as I said earlier, that they are named by consumers when they're in these agentic experiences. That's going to come through really focusing on how they develop that connection with the customer at the end of the day.
Sean Nolan: Thank you. I think it's a really astute observation that it's up to the brands to own that post-purchase experience. AI may excel in the discoverability phase, but it's up to brands to own what happens after the sale and create that customer journey and that retention afterwards. It's really interesting.
One other topic that is really important when it comes to agentic commerce is trust. I think it remains a really major unanswered question. What's your perspective on the dynamics around trust as businesses cater to AI agents?
Jason Gregory: We speak about trust a lot at VoucherCodes. I'd say it's probably one of the primary drivers of why a consumer chooses us when they're shopping, and it's something we're always focusing on. I think trust, when it comes to agentic experiences, works both ways. Your agent is going to be looking for trusted sources, just like a shopper does. So brands who build that credibility and get pulled into those key journeys as a result will benefit from the work they've already put in place.
The other element of trust with AI more generally is that it's still super early for most consumers. I've read studies recently from Adobe and YouGov where there are such different results in terms of how much consumers are ready to invest in these agentic shopping products and services. I think it shows that we're really at the start of this journey. And it's understandable, because while ChatGPT might be able to help you find a pair of jeans or recommend three restaurants nearby, the reality is most customers will be more nervous about handing over the payment details or the shipping address and having agents genuinely acting on their behalf. At the moment, so many of these, in inverted commas, "agentic experiences" aren't really end-to-end agentic use cases. I think that will come, but at the moment, it's still very early on in that respect.
As a result, I'd expect people will hand over decisions gradually. Those routine, low-risk purchases that you might buy every month, ones where you're invested but not as invested as in a holiday or planning a big event, will be the journeys that people are willing to test out first. And then obviously, as the consumer gains more trust, the role that retailers and brands have will become even more important from a loyalty proposition perspective.
But that trust is easily lost as well. We've seen plenty of examples recently where businesses are really grappling with that when it comes to AI. So it is about walking a narrow pathway in that respect, but it's important for businesses. And that's something we're always thinking about: how we can leverage that trust and credibility within this new age of shopping.
Sean Nolan: Yeah, definitely. One thing we've always seen with trust is that it builds very slowly, but it can be lost very quickly. As agentic shopping and retail becomes more popular, businesses have to evolve with the times and evolve with new technologies that come out around trust, around what makes people feel safe when they're going through checkout but have an agent representing them. That's something we definitely have to keep an eye on moving forward.
Overall, I want to take a step back and get your perspective on the topic more broadly. Where do you think businesses should invest their focus moving forward? Should they focus on keeping those human consumers that they've been serving for decades, centuries? Or do you think they should focus more on the AI agents that are going to be representing shoppers potentially more in the future?
Jason Gregory: My short answer would be that you've always got to put the consumer first. I really believe in that. And I think not everything is a functional, straightforward transaction, as we touched on already. I feel quite strongly that a lot of the agentic commerce examples that we see out there at the moment forget the fact that for many people, for millions of people, shopping is almost a habit that brings them loads of joy. It's something people actually really enjoy and spend hours immersing themselves in. So when you're planning a holiday, or you're planning for a big event like a wedding, you want to be bouncing ideas around with friends and family. You don't want to be handing over the keys, so to speak, for a big life event like that to an agentic commerce agent.
So it is important to remember that there is a consumer with different needs at the end of the product or the experiences that you're delivering. And like I said, I think we'll see agents handle those utility-driven prompts really well. They do that well already. But I think customers will increasingly want to spend with brands that align with their interests, their lifecycle, their values. So brands should be thinking about how that element of their proposition surfaces within these experiences as well.
If I had an AI agent, it's important to remember that my AI agent would have no emotional attachment to a particular retailer. It's literally doing what I ask it to do. It's fulfilling an outcome. So that's quite a different way of thinking about the consumer. It's almost at the other end of the scale from when we talk about consumer first. But I think it's more critical than ever that businesses try to maintain or build a strong connection with the shopper, because ultimately that's going to be the thing that creates the loyalty and the lifetime value. And not all of these AI agents will be able to replicate that, at least in the near term.
Sean Nolan: Absolutely. I think it's important to highlight again the emotional importance of not just shopping, but also that connection with brands. Investing in that emotion will help brands succeed moving forward, because you'll have consumers feeling more strongly that they want to keep coming back, rather than a cold AI agent that thinks purely in terms of numbers and figures and perhaps won't consider those other factors that are really important to the shopping experience. I think that's really interesting.
Jason Gregory: Like we touched on already, there's so much more to most purchases than just the actual purchase itself. When someone is planning a holiday, it's unlikely they're going to want to stop at the top three villas that their AI agent sends back to them. These AI counterparts are going to be equipped with incredible levels of data about you and what you're interested in. But I think that does not necessarily reflect what a lot of consumers like to do, which is to bask a little bit in the process of planning for something like that and really immerse themselves in it. So it is important to remember, as we've touched on already, that there's so much of that purchase experience that comes after the customers actually found what they're looking for.
Sean Nolan: Yeah, absolutely. I think the activity of it is also part of the values, not just the product that they get on the other side of it.
Finally, I want to ask a forward-looking question. As we head into 2027, do you expect to see any major developments in agentic commerce over the next 12 months? Is there anything that we should be keeping an eye out for?
Jason Gregory: This is, again, quite a difficult question to answer, because I think we're living in a time where the capabilities of these experiences are just so much faster and ever-evolving. But it is important to remember that for almost every consumer, this is a really, really new thing. The ability for an agent to go and act on your behalf is just not something most consumers are used to. So I do think it's important to remember, for brands, and we think about this a lot, that most agentic experiences are not genuinely end-to-end agentic experiences when it comes to shopping at the moment. There are great examples of what they could be like in the future, but there are not many where the end-to-end shopping journey has been solved, and certainly none where it's been scaled to any significant extent yet. I would expect that to change in the next 12 months.
I think a number of the big AI companies, but obviously the likes of Google, who have the head start of having so many years of experience working in commerce at their disposal, will accelerate. We already mentioned the Universal Commerce Protocol they've built in conjunction with the likes of Shopify. I think that will help many retailers and brands get a bit of a head start in that space. If I think about next year, the disruption that we're likely to see will come in areas where businesses maybe need to make sure they're ready for it.
If we think about standard protocols like payments, that's very easy to solve. But the bottleneck for some brands will come through the readiness of their data quality: their product catalog availability, offer and stock information, and that kind of thing. A lot of retailers have invested in this as part of personalization efforts in the last five to ten years, so there's no doubt most will be better prepared than they would have been had this come a bit sooner. But it is going to be critical for AI agents to pick these brands out and recommend them to people. I still expect we'll be seeing agents handing off to merchants as well. Like I said already, I just don't think there will be appetite to own this from an agent perspective just yet. That's where I think brands need to make sure they're continuing to remember those loyalty signals of trust and quality and positive emotional connection, because that's what's going to get the customer coming back.
One thing as well, in the context of these experiences, and we definitely look at any new emerging technology through this lens, is that businesses should be thinking small. What are the tests they can do where they can learn fast and understand what does and doesn't work, and then look to scale the features that are driving success? There is so much about this that's new, and there are a lot of unknowns, and a lot of brands are all navigating those together at the same time. So the more you start small and be really focused on what you're trying to achieve, the more businesses can learn and evolve as they see the technology and capabilities, and, most importantly, as the consumer needs in this domain become clearer as well.
Sean Nolan: Yeah, absolutely. Thank you. I think you shared some really practical, helpful advice for brands there about data quality, the availability of products, and things like that. Those are some really practical steps to keep in mind for 2027. As you say, there are a lot of unknowns that we still need to figure out, but that's definitely something we're going to be keeping an eye on. I'm sure you'll be doing the same at VoucherCodes as well. Thank you so much for your time, Jason. Hopefully we can chat again soon and discuss more about agentic commerce in the future.
Jason Gregory: Cool. Thanks, Sean.
Sean Nolan: Thank you for watching. Create your account on CXToday.com for more insights into CX, AI, and agentic commerce.